SP Paper 210

Justice 1 Committee

10th Report, 2004 (Session 2)

CONTENTS

REMIT AND MEMBERSHIP

REPORT

Introduction and background

Evidence taken by the Committee

General reaction to the Bill 

Main provisions

Policy intentions

Existing provisions

What difference will the legislation make to existing provisions?

Alternative approaches

Conclusion

Application of the legislation

Who should be covered?

Emergency circumstances

Wider measures

Policy memorandum

Financial memorandum

Delegated powers

Conclusion of the report

Appendix: General evidence of violence against emergency workers

VOLUME 2

ANNEX A – REPORT FROM THE SUBORDINATE LEGISLATION COMMITTEE

ANNEX B – REPORT FROM THE FINANCE COMMITTEE

ANNEX C – EXTRACTS FROM THE MINUTES

ANNEX D – ORAL EVIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED WRITTEN EVIDENCE

18th Meeting 2004 (Session 2) 5 May 2004

Oral Evidence

Scottish Executive

Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service

Associated Written Evidence

Scottish Executive

Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service

21st Meeting 2004 (Session 2) 26 May 2004

Written Evidence

Scottish Police Federation

Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland

Association of Scottish Police Superintendents

Oral Evidence

Law Society of Scotland

Faculty of Advocates

Scottish Police Federation

Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland

Association of Scottish Police Superintendents

Associated Written Evidence

Law Society of Scotland

22nd Meeting 2004 (Session 2) 2 June 2004

Written Evidence

Chief and Assistant Chief Fire Officers Association

Fire Brigades Union Scotland

Royal College of Nursing (Scotland)

British Medical Association

Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh

T&G Scotland

Oral Evidence

Chief and Assistant Chief Fire Officers Association

Royal College of Nursing (Scotland)

British Medical Association

Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh

Unison Scotland

T&G Scotland

GMB Scotland

Scottish Trades Union Congress

23rd Meeting 2004 (Session 2) 9 June 2004

Written Evidence

Association of Directors of Social Work

British Association of Social Workers

Minister for Finance and Public Services

Oral Evidence

Association of Directors of Social Work

British Association of Social Workers

Prison Officers Association Scotland

Scottish Prison Service – Trade Union Side

Minister for Finance and Public Services

Associated Written Evidence

Minister for Finance and Public Services

26th Meeting 2004 (Session 2) 30 June 2004

ANNEX E – OTHER WRITTEN EVIDENCE

Jackie Baillie MSP

Central Scotland Fire Brigade

COSLA

City of Edinburgh Council

Falkirk Council

Fife Council

Forth Valley Acute Hospitals NHS Trust

Glasgow City Council

Grampian Fire Brigade

Guild of Healthcare Pharmacists

Historic Scotland

Individual

Lothian and Borders Fire Board

National Grid Transco (Scotland)

NHS Borders

NHS Grampian

NHS Greater Glasgow Primary Care Division

NHS Great Glasgow Yorkhill Division

NHS Lothian Primary and Community Division

North Glasgow University Hospitals Division

Royal College of General Practitioners

Royal College of Midwives UK Board for Scotland

Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health Scotland

Sheriffs Association

Scottish Ambulance Service

Scottish Environmental Protection Agency

Scottish Partnership Forum

Scottish Water

SOLACE

Strathclyde Fire Board

UNIFI

USDAW

West Lothian Healthcare Trust